Whether it originated Michigan or Wisconsin Midwesterners question the true flavor of Blue Moon ice cream. Is it lemon, vanilla, cotton candy, or all the above?
Unique to Michigan, Ohio, and Wisconsin, Superman ice cream has no set flavor profile. Flavors range from blue moon, Faygo redpop, cherry, vanilla, and banana.
Created in the 1950s Blue Moon ice cream is a favorite flavor among Midwestern states, especially Michigan, but its true flavor is a mystery to this day.